CDXList

Costello's Rare Coins

Halesite, New York

Address
187 Park Avenue, Halesite, NY, 11743
VerifiedU.S. CoinsBullion

Costello's Rare Coins in Halesite, New York is a U.S. Coins, Bullion dealer listed on CDXList.com. Contact the shop for current inventory, buy/sell pricing, and hours.

Dealer location

Shop address — not a coin show venue.

187 Park Avenue, Halesite, NY, 11743Open in Google Maps

Collector notes

Visiting a coin shop

A few notes before you walk into Costello's Rare Coins in Halesite, NY. These rotate daily. They are general collector etiquette from CDXList — not this shop’s house rules. When something is unclear, ask the person at the counter.

  1. If you feel rushed, you can pause

    You are allowed to say you need a minute. You are allowed to pack up and think. You are not required to decide while someone is waiting behind you — step aside and let them go. A good shop would rather you be sure than sorry.

  2. They do not have to buy what you brought

    A shop can pass on tokens, damaged coins, or a category they do not handle. “We don’t buy that” is information. Ask who might. Do not argue them into a box they cannot use. A clean no today keeps the door open next time.

  3. If you set a time, be on it

    Some shops work by appointment on bigger lots. Be on time. Call if you are late or cannot come. The slot they held is time they did not give someone else. Reliability gets you invited back.

  4. Online asking prices are not what a shop pays

    A listing, a completed auction before fees, and a dealer buy price are three different numbers. Screenshots of asks are not a bid. Bring the coins. Let them look. Then talk. You will get further than arguing from a tab on your phone.

  5. Bring identification on a larger visit

    A license in the car does not help at the counter. If you might sell, buy something expensive, or move cash, bring ID in with you. It speeds things up and avoids an awkward pause after you already agreed.